AI Generated Art: Theft or Evolution of Awesome Creativity?

In the realm of digital creativity, AI image generation technology is pushing the boundaries of what's possible, challenging the misconception that it merely replicates existing art. Through platforms like DALL-E and Midjourney, we explore how machine learning enables AI to produce original artwork. This journey into AI's capabilities reveals the intricate process of training models to recognize and interpret vast datasets, leading to the creation of unique, innovative art.
Ai Generate Art


Let’s forget about AI generated art for a moment and travel back through the sands of time to an era when the world was a canvas waiting to be painted. In the year 40,000 BCE, a caveman with an innate longing for expression stood before a cold cave wall. In a moment of inspiration, he spat out a mixture of water and ochre from his mouth, crafting the first piece of art—a red outline of his hand etched onto the ancient canvas.

Wide-eyed and captivated by the beauty before him, his son felt an unspoken connection to this newfound artistry. With his tiny hand, he echoed his father’s creation, adding a second red outline beside the first. Two hands, distinct yet harmoniously the same, graced the cave wall, a testament to the human spirit’s quest for connection and continuity.

Should we ask ourselves: “Did the child gain more cave-friends because of this cool technique? Did he continue to repeat this art to gain more friends? After all, there is safety in numbers. The child’s handprint could have had more detail, making the outline look better, which, in turn, appealed to more observers. If so, was his father jealous? He did, in fact, do it first. Or perhaps the father’s handprint dripped more, causing some other cave observers to prefer that version better, giving him a round of applause and making the child feel bummed. Whatever the case, I am confident that when the cave people went their own way and mimicked this art form elsewhere, it impressed others.

I often wondered if those primitive artists debated ownership of this groundbreaking process. (I doubt it, but you never know) Their hands, nearly identical yet subtly distinct in size and position, left an imprint on the cave walls that echoed through millennia. Thousands of years later, we stumbled upon their masterpiece, marveling at the beauty of shared human heritage—a story preserved, studied, and reproduced across various mediums in the pursuit of education.

Fast-forward to the brink of the new millennium, where the internet was beginning to boom, and businesses crafted their digital presence. In the year 2000-sish (give or take a few years), websites bore a striking resemblance to each other, mirroring one another with similar page layouts and imagery. Checking out the support pages of hundreds of thousands of websites would reveal a ubiquitous image—a futuristic headset-clad woman symbolizing high-tech assistance. It became a visual narrative, a story told across the vast web landscape. It screamed, “We are high-tech, sophisticated, and cutting-edge.” Was this phenomenon an act of theft or inspiration? Did one company gain clients over the other because of this? We will never know.

ai generated art

Bridging the Divide in Artistic Innovation

The advent of artificial intelligence (AI) has revolutionized numerous industries, and the art world is no exception. The emergence of AI generated art has sparked a vibrant debate among artists, legal experts, and technologists. Is using artificial intelligence in art creation a form of theft, or does it signify an evolution in the creative process? This article delves into the nuances of this discussion, offering a balanced perspective on how AI generated art is reshaping the boundaries of creativity and the art world at large.

Understanding AI Generated Art: The Mechanism Behind the Canvas

Before forming an opinion on the matter, it’s crucial to understand how AI generated art comes to life. Through complex algorithms and machine learning, AI creates artwork based on vast datasets of existing art. These technologies analyze patterns, styles, and techniques from these datasets and generate new pieces of art that are unique yet influenced by the analyzed data. This process, while automated, is not devoid of human input. Humans curate the datasets, and the algorithms are designed and fine-tuned by human programmers.

Check out this great video titled: “How AI Image Generators Work” by Computerphile.

AI and Human Creativity: A Symbiotic Relationship?

The relationship between AI and human creativity is not a one-way street. AI does not merely mimic human creativity; it can also inspire it. Artists have used AI as a tool to explore new creative horizons and produce art that was previously unimaginable. AI can generate novel patterns and styles that can serve as a source of inspiration for artists. In this sense, AI and human creativity can coexist and complement each other, leading to a symbiotic relationship that pushes the boundaries of artistic expression.

The Ethical Debate: Innovation or Infringement?

Navigating the Copyright Labyrinth

One of the primary copyright concerns AI art raises is the question of originality. If an AI generates art based on existing works, does it infringe on the copyright of those works? Current copyright laws are not equipped to handle this question as they were designed in a pre-AI era. The principle of fair use, which allows limited use of copyrighted material without permission, needs to be clarified in the context of AI art. This ambiguity has led to ongoing debates in the art and legal communities about how to adapt copyright laws to the age of AI.

The Artist’s Perspective: Threat or Opportunity?

Artists’ views on AI generated art are diverse. Some see it as a threat to their originality and livelihood, while others see it as an opportunity for growth and innovation. The threat perspective stems from the fear that AI could replicate an artist’s style and produce similar works much faster, thereby devaluing the artist’s work. On the other hand, the opportunity perspective sees AI as a tool that can enhance an artist’s creativity and productivity. This dichotomy reflects the broader debate about the impact of AI on jobs and industries.

The Evolution of Creativity: Expanding the Artistic Lexicon

AI generated art introduces a new lexicon in the art world. It challenges traditional notions of creativity and authorship, potentially leading to a broader understanding and acceptance of what constitutes art. AI in art creation forces us to rethink our definitions of creativity. Is creativity the exclusive domain of humans, or can machines also be creative? This question is not easy to answer, but it is a testament to the transformative impact of AI on the art world.

Case Studies: AI’s Role in Creative Breakthroughs

AI has already made significant inroads into the art world. Several artists and institutions have embraced AI, leading to creative breakthroughs that have gained recognition. For instance, the artwork “Portrait of Edmond de Belamy,” created by the AI algorithm developed by the art collective Obvious, was sold at Christie’s auction house for a staggering $432,500. This event marked a milestone in the acceptance of AI generated art and highlighted the potential of AI to create valuable art.

Fostering an Inclusive Art World: Ethical AI Use

Guidelines and Best Practices

As AI becomes more prevalent in art, it’s crucial to develop and adhere to ethical guidelines for AI in art. These guidelines should address issues such as copyright infringement, fair compensation for artists, and the transparency of AI algorithms. They should also promote fairness and inclusivity in the art community, ensuring that the benefits of AI are accessible to all artists, not just a privileged few.

The Future of AI in Art: A Collaborative Vision

Looking ahead, the relationship between AI and artists is likely to evolve. As AI technologies become more sophisticated and accessible, more artists may incorporate AI into their creative process. This could lead to a future where AI and human creativity coexist and enrich each other, fostering an inclusive and innovative art world.

Conclusion: Embracing the New Era of Artistic Expression

In conclusion, AI generated art is not a black-and-white issue of theft versus originality but a complex evolution of creativity. By understanding the technology, addressing ethical concerns, and fostering collaboration, we can embrace AI’s role as a catalyst for innovation and inclusivity in the art world. As we navigate this new era of artistic expression, it’s crucial to keep the conversation going, inviting diverse perspectives and fostering an open dialogue about the future of art in the age of AI.

I have incorporated a lot of AI in what I do as an artist. It’s cost effective, quick turn-around, and produces results that are visually acceptable. I even have a blog post dedicated to using AI art in unique ways, such as: How Generative AI can Revolutionize Marketing Campaigns with a Medieval and Fantasy Flair.

Additional Resources

For those interested in delving deeper into the intersection of AI and art, here are some additional resources:

These resources offer a wealth of insights into the fascinating world of AI art, providing a comprehensive overview of this rapidly evolving field. From exploring the philosophical implications of AI creativity to practical guides on using machine learning in artistic practice, there’s something for everyone in this exciting new frontier of art and technology.

Medieval & Fantasy Worlds - The Book

This groundbreaking Midjourney Guide unlocks the secrets of creating stunning medieval and fantasy art using the power of MidJourney AI.

Recent Posts

Newsletter Signup
Subscribe to stay informed free downloads, upcoming installments of multi-part articles and other relevant updates.